Question about mandatory criteria evidence - exceptional promise

Stage 1
1

To satisfy the MC under the promise route, can I provide two independent pieces of evidence for “You have held or hold a significant expert role participating on panels, or individually, assessing the work of others in the same field or a field of specialisation related to the digital technology sector.”

The evidence would be:

  • Document 1: Evidence of serving as an industrial supervisor for Master’s thesis students in machine learning at an Oxbridge university. (screenshots of the students thesis showing acknolwedgements + a letter of support from an academic co-supervisor from Oxbridge)
  • Document 2: Evidence of being invited to do peer review at top ML conferences (NeurIPs) and workshops at top ML conferences (e.g. workshops at ICLR). (will show screenshots from OpenReview).

Would this suffice? thank you

2

THE MC should be stronger. The evidences you have listed is great but you could add additional evidences to make your case stronger.

I feel like Document 1 can also be used for OC2 " recognised for my work outside of my immediate occupation that contributed to the advancement of the sector.