I have questions which relates to how the evidence are presented for Mandatory Criteria.
Narrative question, should each of the evidence be treated as combined or separate? meaning to say I am just listing various achievements (separate), or should they weave into a (combined) narrative which shows that I am a leading talent?
Related to the above, on the reference letter (not the 3 recommendation letters), can it cover 2 different evidence?
This will help me strategise the way things are presented.
Narrative question, should each of the evidence be treated as combined or separate? meaning to say I am just listing various achievements (separate), or should they weave into a (combined) narrative which shows that I am a leading talent?
Each evidence set is supposed to be unique and can either present a single narrative or multiple narratives.
For instance:
MC1 - Speaking Evidence (Single Narrative Case Study)
You were invited to speak through a letter or email as a result of your recognition and expertise.
You delivered a talk on stage to an audience of at least 100 people.
You received an appreciation email thanking you for your contribution.
Post event evidence exists, such as the recording being uploaded to YouTube and receiving thousands of views, comments, or other forms of engagement.
As a result of the talk, other professionals contacted you for guidance, or you received invitations to speak at additional events because of the domain knowledge you demonstrated during the session.
As you can see, the above provides enough evidence to comfortably cover the three page limit. Also, everything presented here is uniquely related to speaking.
MC1 - Speaking Evidence (Combined Narrative Case Study)
You were invited to speak at Event A, where you presented on stage to 154 attendees. This can be presented on Page 1.
You were invited to speak at Event B, where you presented on stage to 87 attendees. This can be presented on Page 2.
You obtained a reference letter from Event B that validates your invitation, explains why you were selected to speak, and confirms that additional participants joined online.
These are two examples of speaking evidence that can work.
In Case 1, the narrative revolves around a single speaking engagement supported by substantial evidence. In Case 2, the narrative combines two separate speaking engagements. However, one thing remains constant in both cases: the evidence is uniquely focused on speaking.
What should be avoided is combining speaking, judging, and mentoring into a single evidence set. I mean unrelated evidence.
Doing so weakens the uniqueness and clarity of the evidence because each evidence set should demonstrate a distinct area of contribution and recognition.
Related to the above, on the reference letter (not the 3 recommendation letters), can it cover 2 different evidence?
Yes, a reference letter can cover two distinct pieces of evidence, provided they originate from the same engagement or source and are presented together. However, a reference letter alone is not sufficient evidence. It should be treated as a supporting or validating document that substantiates and support the primary evidence being presented.