Feedback Requested on My Exceptional Talent Application Plan (Experienced Product Manager)

Hi Everyone,

I would appreciate feedback on my application plan for the Ecxeptional Talent/ Experienced Product Manager.

I’ve created a roadmap for the application and selected MC/OC evidence, but I still have a few concerns.

Professional background and intended route

I am applying under the Exceptional Talent route as an experienced Product Manager. I have approximately 16 years of experience in technology, including around seven years in product management. My earlier experience was primarily technical, covering software testing, quality assurance and QA leadership.

I previously worked as a Senior Product Manager at an international SaaS company with offices in the UK, US, India and Palestine. My work focused on data, analytics and AI-supported workforce products for enterprise customers across the UK and US.

For approximately the past four years, I have worked in product leadership at a Palestinian fintech company that builds B2B and B2G digital-finance products. My work has included white-label e-wallets, digital payments, merchant and agent platforms, payment infrastructure, digital leasing, AML/e-KYC capabilities and automated credit-assessment solutions.

Recommendation letters

I have three recommendation letters ready:

  1. The CEO of my current fintech company, who can describe my leadership across regulated fintech products and my progression into the Product Management Lead role.

  2. The CEO of a UK technology company, who was previously VP of Product and my direct manager at the international SaaS company where I worked. He can describe my product leadership, international experience and contribution to data, analytics and AI-related products.

  3. A Director of Product at a UK-based startup, who was previously my colleague at the same international SaaS company. He can provide a separate UK product-industry perspective on my strengths, cross-functional working style and ability to contribute to the UK digital-technology sector.

Mandatory Criterion: Recognition as a leader

MC1: Recognition of my international product leadership

I plan to submit a supporting document from the former Chief Product Officer of the international SaaS company where I worked.

The evidence would confirm:

  • My leadership skills and product impact.

  • My progression and the trust placed in me by senior management.

  • My significant salary increase during my third year with the company.

  • My selection to lead an important core product assignment approximately three months after joining.

  • My responsibility for leading products from product definition and prioritisation through delivery.

  • My role in customer meetings and product discussions with major enterprise clients across the UK and US.

  • My ability to work internationally across product, engineering, data and customer-facing teams.

The product assignment related to analytics, reporting and workforce-data capabilities used by hospitality businesses across multiple locations. The evidence is intended to demonstrate that I was trusted with substantial product responsibility shortly after joining and was recognised internally as a senior product leader.

MC2: Independent client recognition through NeoCash

I plan to submit a letter from NeoCash, a business client of my current company, confirming my product leadership and the trust placed in my judgement.

My company deployed its white-label e-wallet product for NeoCash. The wider platform includes:

  • Customer e-KYC and digital onboarding.

  • Multi-currency wallet capabilities.

  • Peer-to-peer and customer transactions.

  • Card-management capabilities.

  • Agent and merchant operations.

  • POS management and reconciliation.

  • Bill payments and external integrations.

  • Maker-checker and approval workflows.

  • QR issuing and scan-and-pay capabilities.

  • Financial Digital Identity and regulatory enhancements.

The NeoCash letter would describe how I led the product deployment, customer-specific adaptations, integrations, testing, data migration and continuing product improvements. It would also confirm my understanding of regulated financial requirements, including e-KYC, AML and Palestine Monetary Authority requirements.

The purpose of this evidence is primarily to demonstrate independent recognition of my leadership, rather than only the commercial impact of the product.

MC3: Recognition beyond my immediate employment

I am considering adding evidence of external recognition through:

  • Speaking sessions organised by IEEE.

  • Speaking engagements with Google Developer Groups.

  • Expert sessions delivered to university students.

  • Participation in professional technology events.

  • Mentoring through structured or government-supported technology initiatives.

  • Mentorship and activities supporting women and girls in technology.

I understand that this evidence needs to show genuine external recognition, clear selection criteria, meaningful audiences and activity beyond my ordinary employment responsibilities.

Optional Criterion 3: Significant technical or commercial contribution

This is currently my strongest optional criterion.

OC3.1: Yabous Finance national closed-loop wallet

My strongest contribution evidence relates to Yabous Finance, a national financial-resilience initiative introduced by the Palestinian Ministry of Finance.

The Ministry adapted our company’s white-label e-wallet product as a closed-loop financial solution to address severe cash and salary-payment constraints. The platform enables eligible government employees to use part of the financial entitlements owed to them by the government to settle essential obligations directly with approved billers. It does not support cash withdrawals or ordinary person-to-person transfers.

The product contribution included:

  • Adapting the e-wallet into a closed-loop model.

  • Integration with government employee records.

  • Verification of employee eligibility during onboarding.

  • Transaction and amount controls.

  • Approved-biller integrations.

  • Operational and reporting capabilities.

  • Maker-checker controls.

  • Transaction monitoring and auditability.

  • Rapid deployment within a highly challenging economic and operational environment.

The supporting evidence will include Ministry confirmation, reporting extracts carrying the client’s logo and signature, product requirements documents showing my name and relevant public press coverage.

Since its pilot launch in June 2026, the platform has expanded to more than 78,000 approved users. I can also include transactions supported and transactional value. This is significant, taking into consideration the limitations of our market (Palestinian market)

The evidence will explain my role as Product and QA Lead in translating the Ministry’s operational and control requirements into product capabilities, coordinating integrations, releases, and user acceptance testing, and supporting the platform’s deployment within approximately three months.

OC3.2: Second significant product contribution still under consideration

I am still deciding which product should be used as my second OC3 document.

My available options include:

  • A live merchant and customer platform developed through a product partnership with Qredit, a product-led fintech company. I worked as Product Lead on specific customer-application and merchant-platform capabilities. To use this effectively, I would need independent confirmation from Qredit and measurable figures covering merchants, active customers, transactions, adoption or commercial impact.

  • A payment-gateway product to which I contributed. The solution provides payment APIs and related integration capabilities for merchants and digital platforms. However, I was not its principal Product Lead, so I am concerned that it may not demonstrate a sufficiently significant personal contribution.

  • NeoCash’s measurable product growth and adoption. However, because NeoCash is already being considered under MC as evidence of leadership recognition, I am cautious about relying on the same product under two criteria, even if the OC3 document uses separate evidence and focuses only on measurable contribution and impact.

I am therefore currently short of a clearly differentiated second OC3 product with impact evidence as strong as Yabous Finance.

Optional Criterion 4: Academic research

I have prepared OC4 evidence, although I recognize that this may be one of the weaker parts of my application.

OC4.1: Published fintech research

I am the first author of a fintech-related research chapter titled:

“Analysis of the E-Payment Industry in Palestine Using Porter’s Six Forces Model.”

The research:

  • Was presented at the 10th International Conference on Business and Technology in 2024.

  • Was accepted following the conference publication process.

  • Was published by Springer as a chapter in Big Data in Finance: Transforming the Financial Landscape.

  • Has the chapter DOI 10.1007/978-3-031-75095-3_50.

  • Analyses the competitive, regulatory and commercial environment of Palestine’s e-payment industry.

  • Provides industry-level recommendations concerning financial inclusion, younger underserved customers, regulatory barriers, local partnerships, customer trust and digital-payment market entry.

The evidence is supported by a letter from the Director of the PhD programme in Management and Economics and former Dean of the Business School, who taught me during my MBA and supervised the development of the work from a course assignment into a published chapter.

I understand that the main limitations are that this is one co-authored publication, it is relatively recent, and it currently has limited evidence of citations, industry adoption or independent academic recognition.

OC4.2: First-place fintech seminar research

My second research item is an MBA seminar titled:

“Key Factors Influencing Mobile Wallet Adoption Intentions Among Generation Z in Palestine.”

The research received First Place for Best MBA Seminar in 2025. It focused on mobile-wallet adoption and connected academic research with practical fintech and financial-inclusion challenges.

The evidence is supported by a letter from the academic supervisor who directly supervised the research. She also confirms that I achieved the highest overall grade in the MBA programme and ranked first among my peers.

However, the seminar has not yet been published, which may limit its strength for OC4. I do not currently have a third strong research publication or academic-impact item.

Optional Criterion 1: Innovation

OC1 has been difficult to build because two pieces of evidence are required, while many of the main products I have led are already being considered under MC or OC3.

My current OC1 options are:

OC1.1: Harri IQ workforce analytics

Harri IQ is a workforce-intelligence and analytics product developed for hospitality businesses operating across multiple locations.

The product brings together workforce, scheduling, labour, sales and operational information to provide:

  • Centralised reporting and analytics.

  • Custom dashboards and reporting.

  • Role- and location-based insights.

  • Workforce and labour-performance visibility.

  • Demand and operational intelligence.

  • Predictive or AI-supported capabilities.

  • Self-service access to workforce data for non-technical users.

My evidence would explain why Harri IQ represented an innovative step beyond static reporting by turning fragmented workforce data into an embedded, interactive intelligence product for hospitality operators.

I can request a supporting letter from Harri’s former Director of Big Data and AI, who led the product from the technical side and worked directly with me. The letter could confirm my product role, collaboration with the data and engineering teams, contribution to product definition and delivery, and the business or customer impact of the analytics platform.

OC1.2: AI-assisted credit-study automation

The second innovation evidence relates to an AI-assisted credit-study module within our digital-leasing product.

The solution combines:

  • Existing customer and e-KYC information.

  • AML screening.

  • Palestine Monetary Authority credit information.

  • Credit-facility and exposure data.

  • Returned-cheque information.

  • Relevant legal indicators.

  • AI-assisted bank-statement analysis.

  • Financial obligations and debt-burden ratio calculations.

  • Consolidated credit scoring and risk indicators.

  • A regenerable credit-study report for professional human review.

The innovation lies in consolidating previously fragmented and substantially manual checks into one structured and auditable credit-assessment workflow for individual and corporate leasing customers.

The supporting evidence would include:

  • A high-level solution-architecture diagram.

  • Product requirements documents and screenshots demonstrating my contribution.

  • Product-interface screenshots.

  • A letter from Ritz Leasing confirming my product leadership.

  • Confirmation of the solution’s use on real customer cases.

  • Initial evidence of reduced credit-study processing time.

  • Confirmation that the solution improves auditability, PMA reporting and the availability of historical credit-decision records.

The customer-facing leasing application remains in UAT, but the credit-study module has been tested and used on real case scenarios. I would therefore limit the evidence to the credit-study capability rather than presenting the entire leasing platform as fully live.

Current concern and intended approach

My strongest evidence is currently:

  1. Yabous Finance under OC3.

  2. Harri and NeoCash leadership under MC.

  3. Harri IQ and credit-study automation under OC1, although both require stronger independent confirmation and measurable impact.

  4. Published research and the first-place seminar under OC4, although I recognise that OC4 may remain weaker because of limited citations and independent research impact.

My main unresolved decision is whether to proceed with OC1 and OC3, or rely on OC3 and OC4. I am currently leaning towards OC1 and OC3 because they align more directly with my professional background and product-leadership narrative, but I want to ensure that the innovation evidence is sufficiently strong and does not appear to stretch customer adaptations into innovation claims.

I would appreciate critical feedback on:

  • Whether the overall narrative is coherent for Exceptional Talent.

  • Whether MC demonstrates recognition beyond competent performance.

  • Whether Harri IQ and credit-study automation are sufficiently differentiated and innovative for OC1.

  • Which product would be strongest for OC3.2.

  • Whether OC4 is worth including or should remain only a backup.

  • Whether using different evidence about NeoCash under both MC and OC3 would create excessive overlap.

  • Whether the application sufficiently establishes Block Builders as a product-led fintech company rather than a development or consultancy business.

    • We operate as a product-led fintech company with our own proprietary products and intellectual property, while also undertaking selected fintech product-development, integration and digital-transformation projects (would this be risky?).

Thanks.

Your narrative is coherent, but the evidence must prove recognition and contribution, not just senior responsibility. Progression, salary growth and being trusted with a major assignment show your employer valued your work; they do not alone establish recognition as a leader in the wider field. The client letter is stronger if it explains why your judgement was recognised independently, with specific examples, rather than mainly confirming a successful deployment. The referees’ direct knowledge and distinct perspectives matter more than their titles.

OC1 needs a clear account of what was new and what you personally contributed. Combining familiar checks or adapting a product for a customer is not automatically innovation. Explain the previous practice, what changed, your role and evidence the capability was used. Keep the credit-module claim to the part tested on real cases, separate from the wider application in UAT. Harri IQ also needs proof of what went beyond reporting and established analytics.

Yabous is the clearest OC3 starting point if independent records connect your decisions to its deployment and impact. Choose a second contribution with strong proof of your role and measurable results; a smaller product with clear attribution may serve you better than a larger one where your contribution is hard to isolate. Reusing NeoCash needs distinct claims and evidence. Keep OC4 in contention if the publication and academic endorsement meet the Guide’s research standard. For the company, explain that revenue primarily comes from its own technology and how project work fits that model.

Bluntly, this is not yet an Exceptional Talent application. It demonstrates a highly experienced Product Manager trusted by employers and clients, but not yet someone recognised as a leader across the wider digital-technology sector. Yabous Finance is the only evidence currently approaching that threshold.

MC is the main weakness. MC1 is internal progression and strong job performance. MC2 is client confirmation of a successful deployment and fits OC3 better. MC3 remains a list of possible activities rather than established evidence. Speaking or mentoring only helps where you can prove meaningful selection, platform standing, audience and sustained impact. On the current plan, MC may fail before the optional criteria are considered.

Yabous is your strongest OC3 evidence because it combines government confirmation, public reporting, 78,000 approved users and measurable national impact. Focus on your personal decisions and their consequences, not a long description of the platform. Use Qredit as OC3.2 only if you can obtain independent attribution and credible adoption or commercial figures. Otherwise, move NeoCash from MC to OC3.

Both OC1 claims are vulnerable. Harri IQ currently reads as an analytics platform using established capabilities. The credit module appears to consolidate familiar checks into a workflow and remains partly in UAT. Without market comparison, a clearly distinct concept, live adoption and external validation, either could be treated as ordinary product development rather than innovation.

The Springer publication is credible OC4 evidence, but the unpublished MBA seminar is much weaker. OC3 and OC4 may be safer than stretching the current products into OC1.

Your referees are also concentrated within your employment network, while Block Builders must be proven product-led through IP ownership, reusable products, licensing or product revenue and customer adoption.

I would not submit this configuration yet. Rebuild MC around genuine independent recognition and use Yabous as the standard for every other evidence document. Sixteen years of experience supports the Talent route, but seniority and complex responsibilities do not establish Exceptional Talent by themselves.