MC criteria Confirmation

Good afternoon everyone, I have few questions I need clarification on​:folded_hands:.

‎I want to clarify my proposed evidence documents for the MC evidence Criteria which says showing innovation as a founder of a product led digital company

‎I have built an application called Stryde, which enables users to create habits and goals offline which will be synchronized with the cloud database during internet connection, also enable the to set frequent remainders on goals and habits.

‎I have few users registered already, but the app is not a registered business and doesn’t have any business metrics . But I have plans for future improvements and making it a registered business

‎So the are my proposed evidence documents

‎MC Evidence Document 1 of 3: Technical Leadership and offline-first state synchronization in Stryde.

PAGE 1:

‎1.Executive Summary

‎2.Technical Scope and individual ownership: Stating my role as the lead architect and full-stack developer, stating key leadership milestones.

‎3. System architecture blueprint

‎Page 2: Deep technical implementation and proof of code ownership

‎4. The engineering problem: conflict free offline synchronization. Here I’m explaining the technical solution i applied

‎5.Code base artifacts and pull: Screen shots showing the offline database schema definition and synchronization hook

‎6.live deployment and production metrics: product deployment screen shots and database dashboard, table metrics of registered

‎7.Independent technical evaluation / mentor statement: Technical attestation from senior industry peer stating how he knows my work and how it contributes to the digital technology sector and potrays me as a potential leader.

‎ MC Document Evidence 2 of 3: Cross-Border Software delivery & Operational Impact for Uk Healthcare Providers

‎Evidence type: Live production web systems, clients deliverables and operational Impact

‎PAGE 1:

‎1. Executive Summary explaining my client work

‎2. Provide Information and evidences about the website I built: live url, screenshot of home and services infrastructure, screen shot of dynamic application portal and form handling interface

‎3. Architecture and component Hierarchy diagrams

‎PAGE 2:

‎4. Measurable Operational Outcomes

‎5. Formal Client verification and commendation from the UK company

‎MC Document 3 of 3: Providing mentorship for tech intenrns at HIIT Plc

‎1. Evidence of an official letter confirming the mentorship and technologies I thought.

‎2. Photograps of me mentoring students

‎3. Evidence of my impacts on students and their progress

‎4. Final letter at the end of the mentorship

The first issue is the criterion: innovation as a founder is an optional criterion, while the mandatory criterion is recognition by others as a leading or potential leader in digital technology. The material you describe for Stryde mainly shows what you built and your role in building it. Code, architecture diagrams and a mentor’s technical assessment can support your account, but they do not by themselves show independent recognition of you.

Stryde may be relevant to OC1 if you can show that the product is genuinely innovative and has reached the market with meaningful traction. It may also support OC3 if you can demonstrate significant impact and your personal contribution. Being unregistered is not, by itself, the key issue; the gap is that you say there are no business metrics, so the product’s traction and impact are not yet clear. Client websites can show delivery and client impact, but bespoke client work does not automatically establish innovation as a founder of a product-led company.

The mentorship could support OC2 if it was structured, sustained, voluntary and beyond your normal role. Letters and photos need to establish that context and the outcomes for the mentees. On the evidence described, the main gap is independent recognition for MC; decide which optional criterion each piece genuinely proves before building the documents around it.

I really appreciate the review :folded_hands:

Hi @Ppryme,

As @Akash_Joshi rightly pointed out, the main issue here is the criterion. The evidence you’ve described is primarily focused on building and innovating on your own product, which naturally aligns more with OC1 rather than Mandatory Criteria.

That said, because it is your product, it may still be possible to position some aspects of it under MC if you can clearly demonstrate that you led the product’s growth, the technical direction, or the development team within a digital technology business. The key is having strong evidence to support that narrative.

However, based on what you’ve outlined, the innovation elements would generally fit better under OC1, assuming the evidence meets the requirements of that criterion.

My suggestion would be to go through the Tech Nation guide again and take some time to understand exactly what each criterion is looking for before allocating your evidence. It will make it much easier to determine where each piece of evidence is strongest and most relevant.

All the best.